Lichen
Communities
Methods
A detailed chapter of
lichen community field methods is available
in PDF format or online
in the national FIA
Methods Handbook (see field guides section, phase 3
measurements).
We present below a brief summary of methods.
Data Acquisition
Field
procedures were designed to be conducted
by non-lichenologists
for
practical reasons of staffing field
crews. Data is collected in the field
by FIA field crews each summer. Prior
to the field season, each crew participates
in a 3 day intensive training in lichen
communities methods. Only crews who
pass the certification test at the
end of training are allowed to collect
lichen
data. To be certified, crews must
attain the required measurement quality
objective
(MQO) of collecting 65% of an expert's
species capture on the same plot.
The
method has two parts that are performed
simultaneously. (1) In each standard
0.38 ha FIA plot (see methods
chapter for plot design and field
methods) the field crew searches for
macrolichens on woody plants and collects
a sample of each lichen believed to
be distinct species. Tree and shrub
bases below 0.5 m are excluded from
sampling. Lichens on fallen branches
and other lichen litter may be included.
Given the large plot area, fallen branches
typically provide an excellent sample
of the canopy lichens. The collection
represents the species diversity of
macrolichens in the plot as fully as
possible, with a maximum time limit
of 2 hours. (2) The field crew estimates
the abundance of each species using
a four-step scale: 1 = rare (< 3
individuals in plot); 2 = uncommon (4-10
individuals in plot); 3 = common (> 10
individuals in plot but less than half
of the boles and branches have that
species present); and 4 = abundant (more
than half of boles and branches in the
plot have the subject species present).
As plots are finished, specimens are
sent to specialists for identification.
Note that the field crew need not accurately
assign species names to the lichens,
but must be able to distinguish among
species, and be able to estimate abundances
accurately.
Quality
Assurance (QA)
Reliability and Repeatability
FIA
lichen communities methods have been studied intensively
for reliability
and repeatability. The ultimate measurement quality objective
(MQO) for a plot lichen sample is for repeated measurements
of the same plot on the same year to produce climate and
air quality scores that are within 10% of one another.
In a
study of multiple crews and experts (McCune
et al., 1997) on the same plots, it was determined
that:
-
there was a tight clustering
(<10% difference) of both
expert and crew gradient scores
even
though the number of species
found by experts
and crews differed greatly
-
scores from multiple
observers on the same plots clustered
tightly (<10% difference) along both
climate and air quality gradients
-
so long as crews collected
at least 65% of the species obtained
by experts on the same plot,
plot scores
on air quality and climate gradients achieve
desired MQO's
Assuring Crew MQO's
Based on
the findings above, a crew score of
at least 65% of expert species
richness on the same plot is required
in training certification. Crews who
do not meet this standard are not
allowed to collect data. In most regions,
crew
species capture is 70-85% of expert
scores.
After training, errors are further
minimized by in-season audits (hot
checks), and achievement of MQOs is assessed
with plot remeasurement by experts
(cold
checks). Hot checks are conducted
1-2 weeks into the field season and serve
for mentoring, troubleshooting, and
recertification via simultaneous expert
and crew measurement of a plot. Cold
checks were piloted in 1999 as a blind
check of crew performance. In this
procedure,
experts remeasure 1-2 completed plots
per crew member, selecting these at
random later in the season. Experts
for both hot and cold checks are chosen
by the indicator advisors, and must
themselves pass an expert certification.
Specimen Identification
To ensure high scientific standards,
identification of all crew and QA plot
samples is conducted by lichen experts.
Taxonomic data quality is spot checked
by the indicator advisors, and problematic
material is sent out to taxonomists
for determination. Herbarium vouchers
are made for a subset of the collections
in each region each year. and all field
specimens are stored by the indicator
advisors. Vouchers are stored at several
herbaria, as noted in regional reports.
More Information on QA
The lichen
indicator training and QA and the
lichen
identification specialist documents describe procedures
followed to maintain field and lab data quality. All state
and regional reports provide QA results for data covered
in the reports.
Some documents on this page are in PDF format.
You can obtain a free
PDF reader from Adobe.
|